In the LO Talent War, Support May Beat Signing Bonuses – NMP Skip to main content

In the LO Talent War, Support May Beat Signing Bonuses

Nov 20, 2026
IGNITE Recap 11_20

NEXA Lending and West Capital executives share how they attract top producers, structure recruiting incentives, and build teams in a competitive market

Support and operations topped the list of reasons LOs would consider switching companies during a recent National Mortgage Professional webinar, suggesting that lenders and brokerages competing for talent may need to offer more than attractive compensation packages.

The finding emerged during NMP's Nov. 17 LO Talent War Ignite session, featuring Jason duPont, COO and executive partner at NEXA Lending, and Matthew Blackmer, senior vice president of business development at West Capital Lending.

The two executives discussed how recruiting strategies are evolving in a challenging production environment, why signing incentives deserve closer scrutiny, and what lenders and broker owners can do to attract successful originators.

Support Leads, but Compensation Remains a Factor

During an audience poll asking what would prompt originators to consider changing companies, support and operations ranked first, followed by leadership.

DuPont said he has seen similar results during NEXA recruiting calls, although the conversations that follow often tell a different story.

"When I would talk to them after they were on the Zoom, they'd always go back to comp," he said.

Originators may identify operational support as their biggest concern, but compensation remains central to their final decision.

Blackmer said recruiting conversations have become more individualized as lenders and originators contend with a difficult market.

Rather than immediately pitching West Capital's platform, he focuses on identifying what an originator could be doing differently and whether the company has resources to help.

"My job isn't to sit here and sell you. My job is to see what you're not doing and see whether or not I can help you do that," Blackmer said.

He said those conversations increasingly involve examining whether originators are taking full advantage of marketing tools, social media, coaching, and other resources already available to them.

Two Approaches to Signing Incentives

The executives outlined different approaches to one of the industry's most competitive recruiting tools: signing bonuses.

Blackmer said West Capital does not offer cash signing bonuses or direct cash infusions into recruits' businesses. Instead, the company may provide marketing resources to help incoming originators get started.

He said approximately 70% of West Capital's business involves originators using aggregate marketing and focusing on direct-to-consumer lending, making marketing assistance particularly valuable.

"We're not here to golden handcuff anyone," Blackmer said.

NEXA takes a different approach.

DuPont described the company's sign-on loan program, under which originators receive an upfront loan and repay it through deductions equivalent to 25 basis points on each funded loan.

The deductions reduce the outstanding balance until the loan is repaid. DuPont said the arrangement does not require artificially increasing the rate sheet offered to the originator.

He contrasted that structure with traditional signing agreements that may require originators to repay substantial amounts if they leave before a specified term expires.

"We don't want you to be strapped to us," DuPont said. "We just want hey, we'll give this to you. You pay it down as you go."

But he cautioned that incentives always come with a cost.

"There's no like free money. There's always a cost," DuPont said.

Recruiting Entire Teams Takes Time

Blackmer pointed to West Capital's recruitment of Scott Davis and his team as an example of how a major recruiting opportunity can develop over time.

The team had grown to approximately 78 originators as of Nov. 16, Blackmer said, compared with the roughly 50 referenced earlier in the discussion.

Rather than beginning with a direct recruiting pitch, Blackmer said West Capital focused on building visibility, sharing the success stories of existing originators, and establishing relationships long before a formal conversation took place.

"A lot of it is positioning. So much of it is positioning," Blackmer said.

He said Davis had first viewed his LinkedIn profile approximately nine months earlier, illustrating how long a major recruiting opportunity can develop.

Blackmer argued that success stories are particularly effective when prospective recruits can realistically envision achieving similar results themselves.

"You want to see a story that's attainable and something that's relatable," he said.

The strategy relies on demonstrating what an originator could accomplish with a different platform rather than simply promising higher compensation.

Looking Beyond Production Numbers

Both executives cautioned against judging prospective recruits solely by their existing loan volume.

DuPont emphasized the importance of identifying people willing to take action, demonstrate humility, and learn from others. Blackmer pointed to curiosity as an especially valuable characteristic, particularly as younger originators develop new approaches to generating business through digital platforms.

"Curiosity to me is always going to be my favorite," Blackmer said.

DuPont offered a different set of characteristics.

"I would say grit, grind, and gratitude," he said.

Those qualities, the executives suggested, can help recruiters identify originators whose current production may not reflect their potential.

DuPont also shared an unconventional prospecting tactic: Asking lower-producing or inactive industry contacts which successful originators they admire.

He described speaking with two people who had produced no loans during the previous year. Rather than dismissing them as recruiting prospects, he asked about the people they looked up to in the business.

The conversations led to introductions to producers generating approximately $25 million and $46 million annually.

"There's never a call that I leave without getting referrals," DuPont said.

The example offered a practical lesson for smaller broker owners and branch managers looking to expand without the resources of a national recruiting operation.

A recruiting pipeline does not have to begin with the industry's highest-producing originators. Relationships with people throughout the business can lead to valuable introductions.

A Recruiting Strategy Built on Relationships

Throughout the discussion, both executives returned to the importance of understanding an originator's needs before proposing a move.

For companies competing against larger organizations, that may mean demonstrating how operational support, marketing assistance, and leadership can help producers grow their businesses.

It also means looking beyond immediate recruiting opportunities and developing relationships that may take months to produce results.

As the competition for experienced originators continues, the executives' message was that compensation can attract attention, but a company's ability to deliver on its promises may ultimately determine whether an originator makes the move.

The webinar was hosted by NMP CEO Andrew Berman as part of the NMP Ignite series, which brings mortgage industry leaders together to discuss the challenges and opportunities facing originators, lenders, and broker owners.

Missed the conversation? Visit the LO Talent War event page for more information about the session.

Stay connected with NMP Ignite. Visit National Mortgage Professional's events page to explore upcoming webinars and industry events. NMP's educational sessions bring together industry experts to share practical strategies, emerging trends, and insights to help mortgage professionals grow their businesses.

About the author
Published
Nov 20, 2026
More from
Career
In the LO Talent War, Support May Beat Signing Bonuses

NEXA Lending and West Capital executives share how they attract top producers, structure recruiting incentives, and build teams in a competitive market

Nov 20, 2026
Emerging LO Issue 1 2026

The Accidental Broker: Taylor Behm on the career path he never saw coming

Aug 24, 2026
The Race To Reinvent Mortgage Origination

Automation promises to strip away administrative work while raising expectations for production, conversion, and human advice

Aug 19, 2026
She Doesn’t Need A Co-Signer Anymore

Single women are now buying more homes than single men

Aug 05, 2026
AI-Powered Study Tool Expands Into Mortgage Licensing Education

Personalized study tool is designed to help future loan originators focus on knowledge gaps and prepare more efficiently for licensing exams

Jun 02, 2026
The Dhandho Approach To Mortgage Recruiting

Why writing on LinkedIn is one of the highest-returning capital allocations a mortgage CEO can make

May 28, 2026