BAC Pushes CFPB to Change QM Broker Compensation Rules
Broker Action Coalition wants lender-paid broker compensation excluded from Qualified Mortgage fee calculations, arguing current rules put independent brokers at a disadvantage and discourage small-dollar lending
The Broker Action Coalition (BAC) has taken its fight over mortgage broker compensation to Washington, submitting a proposal to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) that would change how lender-paid broker compensation is treated under Qualified Mortgage (QM) rules.
The proposal, outlined in a white paper released Wednesday, seeks to eliminate a longstanding disparity between independent mortgage brokers and retail lenders. Under current regulations, compensation paid by a wholesale lender to a mortgage broker counts toward the QM points-and-fees limit, while compensation a retail lender pays its employee loan officers does not.
BAC wants lender-paid broker compensation excluded from that calculation, without changing the existing fee limits or federal loan originator compensation and anti-steering rules.
BAC argues that the distinction was created by the CFPB rather than Congress. The bureau excluded compensation paid to retail lenders' employee loan officers when it adopted the QM rules in 2013, but retained lender-paid broker compensation in the calculation. The coalition contends the CFPB has authority to extend that exclusion to independent brokers without congressional action.
Brendan McKay, BAC's co-founder and chief advocacy officer, told NMP that the white paper has been sent to the CFPB and is being distributed to congressional offices.
"We've had conversations with the CFPB about this issue in the past, and they knew the white paper was coming," McKay said.
How the Rule Affects Brokers
For 2026, QM rules generally limit points and fees to 3% of the loan amount on mortgages of $137,958 or more. Smaller loans are subject to graduated dollar and percentage limits.
BAC argues that counting lender-paid broker compensation against those limits leaves brokers with substantially less room for other charges than retail lenders originating comparable loans.
Consider a $175,000 mortgage with lender-paid broker compensation of 2.5%. Under the current calculation, the broker's $4,375 compensation counts toward the $5,250 points-and-fees ceiling, leaving just $875 for other charges subject to the limit.
A retail lender paying an employee LO equivalent compensation would not count that payment toward the cap.
The disparity becomes particularly difficult on smaller mortgages, BAC argues, because fixed origination expenses consume a greater share of the available fee allowance.
McKay said the effect may extend beyond loans that require fee waivers or compensation reductions. Brokers may simply be less inclined to pursue small-balance business.
"Brokers aren't necessarily turning borrowers away because those loans aren't profitable. But that doesn't mean they're actively pursuing them, either," he said.
"A borrower doesn't have to be formally denied a mortgage for a regulation to affect their access to credit. The absence of lenders actively competing for their business can have an impact, too."
A Fed Review Creates an Opening
The timing is deliberate.
The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, enacted in July, requires the CFPB to report to Congress on LO compensation practices and their effects on small-dollar mortgage availability. A separate provision directs the bureau, in consultation with HUD and the FHFA, to evaluate how QM points-and-fees thresholds affect small-dollar lending.
Both requirements carry an April 7, 2027, deadline.
"The ROAD to Housing Act was actually a major factor in our decision to prioritize this issue now," McKay said.
BAC is pursuing both regulatory and legislative changes. Its white paper proposes an amendment to Regulation Z that would exclude qualifying lender-paid broker compensation from QM points and fees, along with a corresponding change to federal law.
The proposal adds another dimension to the industry's broader compensation reform debate. While much of that discussion has centered on flexibility for employee loan officers, BAC is targeting a separate restriction affecting the wholesale channel.
The Community Home Lenders of America (CHLA) raised similar concerns about the economics of small FHA mortgages, arguing that existing LO compensation restrictions could prevent financial incentives from reaching originators who make those loans.
Keeping Consumer Protections Intact
BAC's proposal would preserve the existing QM points-and-fees limits, along with federal prohibitions on steering borrowers toward loans that generate higher compensation.
The proposed exclusion would apply only to compensation funded through the interest rate under a standing agreement that complies with federal LO compensation rules. Borrower-paid compensation, financed charges, and other fees already subject to the QM limit would continue to count.
The CFPB originally retained lender-paid broker compensation in the points-and-fees calculation partly because of concerns about steering consumers into more expensive mortgages.
BAC argues that existing LO compensation and anti-steering restrictions already address those risks.
To support its argument that the change would not lead to widespread compensation increases, BAC cites 2026 production data from two wholesale lenders representing $13.4 billion in funded loans. Its analysis found that most loans in the sample closed with broker compensation below 2.75%.
The proposal now heads into a federal review that could shape future changes to the QM framework. For independent brokers, the question is whether Washington will revisit a compensation restriction that BAC argues has long put them at a disadvantage against retail lenders.
For now, the proposal remains an advocacy effort. The CFPB has not announced a change to the rule, and BAC has received no formal response to its submission.
The upcoming federal reviews give the coalition an opportunity to make its case. Whether the CFPB recommends changing the treatment of broker compensation remains to be seen.