Condo Reserve Hike Could Restrict Financing, Trade Groups Warn
Five trade groups want FHFA to postpone tougher Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac requirements, warning that the changes could further restrict conventional condo financing
Five housing and mortgage industry groups are urging federal regulators to delay an upcoming increase in condominium reserve requirements, warning that the change could make it harder for some buyers and existing owners to obtain conventional mortgage financing.
In a Nov. 19 letter to Federal Housing Finance Agency Director William Pulte, the coalition asked for a one-year extension of the new Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reserve standard, currently scheduled to take effect Jan. 4, 2027.
The requirement will increase the minimum annual reserve allocation for applicable condominium projects from 10% to 15% of budgeted assessment income. The groups want implementation postponed until Jan. 4, 2028.
The request comes just months after the government-sponsored enterprises eliminated their Limited and Streamlined Review options, requiring more extensive financial reviews for many condo projects.
The coalition argues that the combined changes could further reduce the number of properties eligible for conventional financing.
"Condominium project eligibility has already declined following recent changes to project review requirements, including the elimination of Limited Review options," the groups wrote.
Another Hurdle for Condo Financing
The letter was signed by the Community Associations Institute, Community Association Roundtable, Community Home Lenders of America, Housing Policy Council, and National Association of Mortgage Brokers.
The groups support stronger condominium reserves but argue that many associations cannot adjust their budgets quickly enough to meet the new requirement.
Some operate on annual budget cycles, while others may need updated reserve studies, board approvals, or homeowner consultations before increasing reserve contributions.
The coalition also wants FHFA to clarify how existing reserve balances, recently completed reserve studies, and ongoing capital improvements will be treated.
Those questions have implications for lenders reviewing condominium projects. An association that cannot meet the higher reserve requirement or qualify through an acceptable reserve study alternative could have difficulty maintaining eligibility for Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac financing.
That could leave buyers with fewer loan options and make it harder for existing owners to sell or refinance. The groups also warn that some borrowers could be pushed toward non-agency or portfolio financing, which may be more expensive or less readily available.
The coalition singled out older buildings, smaller communities, and associations with modest-income homeowners as potentially more vulnerable to the changes.
Higher Dues Could Affect Borrower Qualification
The letter also raises concerns about affordability, particularly for borrowers already close to debt-to-income limits.
Fannie Mae estimates the higher reserve allocation could increase monthly condominium costs by an average of $13 to $14 per unit.
The coalition's attachment illustrates how costs could vary if associations fund the entire increase through higher regular assessments.
For a homeowner paying $300 in monthly association dues, the illustrative increase would be $15. At $500 in dues, it would be $25, while an association charging $800 could see an additional $40 per month.
Higher association dues count toward a borrower's monthly housing expenses and could affect mortgage qualification.
Fannie Mae, however, says most condominium projects already meet its requirements. The agency also allows an acceptable reserve study as an alternative to the 15% allocation, although the project budget must include the highest recommended reserve contribution identified in the study.
The agency says stronger reserves are intended to help associations prepare for future maintenance and repairs, reducing the risk of unexpected financial burdens on homeowners.
What the January Deadline Means
The higher reserve standard applies to covered loans with application dates on or after Jan. 4, 2027, rather than simply loans scheduled to close after that date.
Freddie Mac has also clarified that lenders must confirm compliance with the new requirements for applications received on or after the effective date, even when an earlier project review remains unexpired.
That makes current association financial documentation particularly important when evaluating condo transactions approaching the deadline.
The latest request follows earlier industry concerns about the cumulative effect of tighter project reviews. The elimination of abbreviated reviews increased the documentation and underwriting work required for many condo loans.
The financing concerns also come amid a difficult condominium market. A recent Redfin analysis found that condo sellers outnumbered buyers by more than two to one nationally in September, with rising association fees and financing restrictions among the challenges facing buyers.
Coalition Seeks More Time
The groups are asking FHFA to use the proposed extension to assess the impact on project eligibility, mortgage availability, and borrower affordability. They also want clearer guidance on reserve study alternatives and transition provisions for associations working toward compliance.
Their request does not seek to eliminate the higher reserve requirement.
"Importantly, our request is not an objection to the objective of responsible reserve funding," the coalition wrote.
The letter asks FHFA to postpone implementation until January 2028. Unless regulators approve an extension, the higher reserve requirement remains scheduled to take effect Jan. 4, 2027.