FHA's Low-Rate Borrowers Boost Insurance Revenue as Lenders Push for Relief
FHA's annual report shows older loans are expected to generate more premium revenue as borrowers stay put, even as industry groups seek lower costs and an end to life-of-loan charges
The Federal Housing Administration's financial strength is renewing a fight over how long borrowers should have to pay mortgage insurance, with two major industry groups pressing for relief even as FHA's latest annual report shows the value of keeping those premiums flowing.
The Community Home Lenders of America (CHLA) on Monday called for an end to FHA's life-of-loan mortgage insurance requirement, while the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) urged a more modest reduction in annual premiums.
Both pointed to FHA's fiscal 2026 report to Congress, which showed the Mutual Mortgage Insurance Fund's capital ratio at 10.29%, more than five times the 2% statutory minimum. The ratio declined from 11.47% a year earlier but remained above the minimum for the 12th consecutive year.
The dispute comes as borrowers with older, low-rate FHA mortgages face a difficult choice: continue paying annual mortgage insurance premiums or refinance into conventional loans, potentially giving up a favorable interest rate.
FHA's own annual report identifies those borrowers as an important source of premium revenue.
In its discussion of future cash flows, FHA said borrowers with loans originated during periods of low interest rates, including 2012 through 2021, are less likely to refinance.
"This will likely result in higher life-of-loan premiums for FHA," the report states.
The agency also identified loans originated from 2020 through 2022 as particularly valuable to its projected cash flows. Those loans generally carry higher insurance premium rates than newer mortgages, have benefited from substantial home price appreciation, and are expected to remain outstanding longer.
A 2013 Policy Under Renewed Scrutiny
FHA adopted its current mortgage insurance duration rules in 2013 as the insurance fund struggled to recover from the housing crisis.
For most FHA loans with case numbers assigned on or after June 3, 2013, borrowers whose original loan-to-value ratio exceeded 90% must pay annual mortgage insurance for the mortgage term. Those with an original LTV of 90% or less generally pay for 11 years.
CHLA argues that the policy has outlived the financial emergency that prompted it.
"With today's MMIF report showing a long-term 12-year run of solid financial performance and bulging FHA reserve levels, it is long past time to stop overcharging homeowners for FHA loans, in order to help them in asset building," CHLA said in its Nov. 16 statement.
The group also pointed to recent federal efforts to make conventional mortgage insurance easier to cancel, along with higher mortgage rates that can make refinancing an unattractive option for existing FHA borrowers.
An October executive order directed the Federal Housing Finance Agency to consider a pilot program for proactive mortgage insurance cancellation on eligible future Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans. The initiative has not established a comparable cancellation benefit for existing FHA borrowers.
MBA Seeks a Measured Reduction
MBA President and CEO Bob Broeksmit took a different approach, calling for lower annual premiums rather than an end to the life-of-loan requirement.
"Our members strongly believe that with the MMIF's capital reserve ratio at 10.29% – more than five times the 2% statutory minimum – FHA should modestly reduce annual mortgage insurance premiums, lowering monthly payments for moderate- and lower-income homebuyers," Broeksmit said.
He urged FHA to pair any reduction with safeguards against multiple risk factors on individual loans.
"Given the slowdown in the housing market, any MIP reduction should be carefully calibrated and paired with additional safeguards to limit multiple layered risk factors on individual loans and protect the fund's long-term health," he said.
The proposal follows MBA's October housing affordability roadmap, which called for a 20-basis-point reduction in FHA's annual mortgage insurance premium, among other administrative changes.
Strong Reserves, But Emerging Risks
The latest FHA report provides support for both the industry's calls for relief and the case for caution.
The forward mortgage program's standalone capital ratio slipped only slightly, from 10.95% to 10.47%. The reverse mortgage program's ratio fell much more sharply, from 24.06% to 5.43%.
FHA attributed pressure on its forward portfolio partly to the 2023 premium reduction, slowing home price appreciation, and updated economic forecasts that increased projected losses.
The report also found that the weighted-average annual premium rate on active forward mortgages declined from 67 basis points to 62 basis points. Annual premiums remain the program's primary cash inflow.
Still, FHA's stress testing showed the combined fund would retain a 2.65% capital ratio under its most severe modeled economic scenario, remaining above the statutory minimum.
For LOs, the debate reaches beyond the price of new FHA loans. Ending life-of-loan premiums could allow qualifying existing borrowers to shed an insurance expense without surrendering their current mortgage rate. A reduction in annual premiums, meanwhile, could improve affordability for new borrowers.
Both proposals would change FHA's premium revenue, leaving HUD to weigh borrower savings against the fund's projected losses and future capital needs.